Two Honourable Gentlemen

"Every person who does a job faces some conflict of interest or the other. There are many people who work for employers whose practices they may not agree with but they don't quit their jobs because of that. Anyway, I don't really think about it as a conflict of interest because every time I comment, I am being completely honest."" - Sunil Gavaskar

---

  "You have to see my body of work over 20 years. It doesn't matter who pays me. I have strong views on cricket which I express freely. If others are offered Board contracts, they should sign up as well," - Ravi Shastri

---

These two are pretty honourable persons- they are, if this Times of India report is true, they are paid Rs.3.6 Crores per year by the BCCI to sit in the commentary box and waffle, and what is more, it is mandatory for any broadcaster who is telecasting cricket matches from India to, oh, yes, include them in the panel of commentators.

Nice line of business, right? I believe that BCCI is rewarding these two gentlemen of extraordinary honesty for their extraordinary honesty. If only they send some of its money along to us, we are quite amenable to speaking our mind volubly and honestly.

Shame on Nasser Hussain, for claiming he is getting paid by the channel to have an opinion- what is wrong if you get money for not having one?

Here, we have plenty of opinions, we can run it any which way you want, but like I said, not being as honourable a gentleman as Ravi or Sunil, no one is paying anything to us at all.

But we are willing, and waiting.

Batsmen Should Walk- or at least acknowledge

There is no way you can get it hundred percent right, no matter how good technology gets- even laser guided missiles get their trajectory wrong, what hope is there for hawkeye and hotspot? So, to wait for perfection is to postpone the adoption of technology. There will always be errors in the game of cricket, and we have to accept that.

There is a way to get round this, and to suggest it is near blasphemy- fine the batsmen if they don't walk. Let the bowlers appeal to the batsmen, and when the batsman refuses to acknowledge that he is out, the umpire on the pitch comes in, and when he is not sure, they all go upstairs. And when it is proved that the batsman was indeed out, he is fined ten percent for not telling that he indeed got an edge.

All batsmen, however great or small, who refuse to walk cheat, relying on the fallibility of the system to pile up some more runs. They need to be made accountable for at least some of the errors that plague this insane game that has become a religion in these parts of the world.

A Heavy Defeat

Trent Bridge came to a disappointing end, devastating in fact.  Ranklings apart, India is still a good team when it is playing full strength, though one wonders whether it will be able to do so any time in the near future.  The players are not gettng younger, and every game carries with it a greater risk of injury, ipl or not.

This is a tricky situation, and unless you have the replacement players doing something brilliant to keep their place in the team, you  can't really tell which way it will go.  I'd like to have Pujara and Badrinath in the team in place of Raina and Yuvraj, brave men both, but they are obviously not great under English conditions. At least, Kohli could have played, though it looks like everything is not perfect about him.

The bowling is the problem area, where are the fast bowlers? Praveen is a game trier,  and he will remain a trier, you need people who can do quick strikes, not one wicker per ten overs or fifteen. You need someone to give you a break and then ask serious questions about the new man in.

Obviously you can ask questions of this sort and feel good about it, India has just had a dismal performance, but if Sehwag plays and Harbhajan goes out giving way to Mishra, we might see something different.  England is shaky, in spite of all those runs, you know their batting could land them in serious trouble- when your openers both can't outlast the new ball your team will get gutted one day or the next. Same as what happened to India.

England are playing at home, but with Sehwag teaming up with Gambhir, you might see a different result. A team does not go from great to worst in two days.