Thursday, April 2, 2009

25 Random Things about Ludwig Wittgenstein- "Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be silent"

1. Ludwig Wittgenstein said, "One of the most misleading representational techniques in our language is the use of the word 'I.'"

2. Wittgenstein also said, "A man will be imprisoned in a room with a door that's unlocked and opens inwards; as long as it does not occur to him to pull rather than push", and, "To pray is to think about the meaning of life", and, "The world of the happy is quite different from the world of the unhappy" , and, "My aim is: to teach you to pass from a piece of disguised nonsense to something that is patent nonsense."

3. But most remarkably, he said, "Hell isn't other people. Hell is yourself", and, "Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be silent", and "Death is not an event in life: we do not live to experience death. If we take eternity to mean not infinite temporal duration but timelessness, then eternal life belongs to those who live in the present. Our life has no end in the way in which our visual field has no limits", and, "If we spoke a different language, we would perceive a somewhat different world", and "The mystical is not how the world is, but that it is."

4. Ludwig's father, Karl Wittgenstein, was an industrialist who made his fortune in iron and steel. By the late 1880s, Karl controlled an effective monopoly on steel and iron resources within the empire, and was one of the richest men in the world. Ludwig's mother, Leopoldine Kalmus, was born to a Jewish father and a Catholic mother, and was an aunt of the Nobel Prize laureate Friedrich von Hayek on her maternal side. Wittgenstein's father died in 1913. On receiving his inheritance, Wittgenstein became one of the wealthiest men in Europe.

5. Ludwig Wittgenstein once asked a pupil if he had ever had any tragedies in his life. The pupil, evidently well trained, inquired what he meant by "tragedy." "I mean suicides, madness, or quarrels," replied Ludwig, three of whose four brothers committed suicide, two of them (Rudi and Hans) in their early twenties, and the third (Kurt) at the age of forty. Ludwig often thought of doing so, as did his surviving brother, Paul. Ludwig claimed to have first entertained thoughts of suicide at around the age of ten, before any of his brothers had died.

6. According to a poll, professional philosophers in Canada and the U.S. rank both his Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus and Philosophical Investigations among the top five most important books in twentieth-century philosophy.

7. In the preface to Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, Ludwig Wittgenstein wrote, "The whole sense of the book might be summed up in the following words: what can be said at all can be said clearly, and what we cannot talk about we must pass over in silence."

8. During an informal discussion between philosophers,  Wittgenstein refused to discuss the Tractatus at all, and sat with his back to his guests while he read aloud from the poetry of Rabindranath Tagore.

9. Once this happened: Popper and Wittgenstein fought over the fundamental nature of philosophy - whether there were indeed philosophical problems (Popper) or merely puzzles (Wittgenstein). Popper writes that he put forward a series of  real philosophical problems. Wittgenstein summarily dismissed them all.  Wittgenstein 'had been nervously playing with the poker', which he used 'like a conductor's baton to emphasize his assertions'. When a question came up about the status of ethics, Wittgenstein challenged him to give an example of a moral rule. Popper writes, 'I replied: "Not to threaten visiting lecturers with pokers." Whereupon Wittgenstein, in a rage, threw the poker down and stormed out of the room, banging the door behind him.' This story developed into one where Wittgenstein attacked Popper with a red-hot poker.

10. Ludwig impressed his musical friends with excellent whistling of classical music.

11. At school, Wittgenstein spoke with a slight stutter, wore very elegant clothes, and was highly sensitive and extremely unsociable. It was one of his idiosyncrasies to use the formal form of address with his classmates and to demand that they too (with the exception of a single acquaintance) address him formally, with "Sie" and "Herr Ludwig"

12. Bertrand Russell remarked that Ludwig Wittgenstein was- "the most perfect example I have ever known of genius as traditionally conceived, passionate, profound, intense, and dominating" When Ludwig attacked some of Russell’s ideas, Russell wrote to Ottoline Morrell, "I couldn’t understand his objection, in fact he was very inarticulate, but I feel in my bones that he must be right."

13. One day, when Paul was practicing at one of the seven grand pianos in their winter home, the Palais Wittgenstein, he leaped up and shouted at his brother Ludwig in the room next door, "I cannot play when you are in the house, as I feel your skepticism seeping towards me from under the door!"

14. During the First World War, Ludwig had read Tolstoy’s "The Gospel in Brief", and other writings that extolled the wisdom of peasants. Resolving to lead a simple life, he gave his share of the family money to three of his siblings; since they were very rich already, he believed they could not be corrupted further by receiving his portion.

15. Michael Frayn has spoofed Wittgenstein, e.g.,

706. One might try to provide the man with a mental picture, a working model of his position--as it were a map to enable him to get his bearings. I might say: "You are in a complete mental fog about the whole business." He seizes on this eagerly. He goes through the motions of assenting--nodding his head, pursing his lips, saying: "Yes, yes, that's it exactly. I am in a complete mental fog." Now one asks: "But how do you know it's a mental fog you're in?"


16. Working as a teacher in a village school, Ludwig Wittgenstein hit a girl so hard that she bled behind the ears, and then belaboured a boy about the head until he slumped unconscious to the floor. While Ludwig was dragging the boy's body off to the headmaster, he bumped into the irate father of the girl whose ears had bled, dropped the unconscious boy and ran away. Then he worked as a gardener, and then tried to enlist as a monk, but was dissuaded.

17. Ludwig Wittgenstein volunteered for the Austro-Hungarian army during the first World War.  In 1916 he was sent as a member of a howitzer regiment to the Russian front, where he won several medals for bravery,

18. Ludwig had had a passion and a facility for mechanical things. At the age of ten, he constructed a working model of a sewing machine out of bits of wood and wire; in 1910, he patented an improvement in propeller technology.

19. After exhausting philosophical work Wittgenstein would often relax by watching a western movie, where he preferred to sit at the very front of the cinema, or reading detective stories.

20. He encouraged several of his students,to find work outside of academic philosophy. There are stories, that if any of his philosophy students expressed an interest in pursuing the subject, he would ban them from attending any more of his classes.

21. Wittgenstein once remarked that he didn't mind at all what he ate, as long as it was always the same thing.

22. "Wittgenstein was an arresting combination of monk, mystic and mechanic. He was a high European intellectual who yearned for a Tolstoyan holiness and simplicity of life, a philosophical giant with scant respect for philosophy. He could never really decide whether he was a Brahmin or an "untouchable"." - Terry Eagleton

23. Ludwig Josef Johann Wittgenstein  (26 April 1889 - 29 April 1951) was an Austrian-British philosopher who worked primarily in logic, the philosophy of mathematics, the philosophy of mind, and the philosophy of language.

24. Final written words: "Someone who, dreaming, says "I am dreaming", even if he speaks audibly in doing so, is no more right than if he said in his dream "it is raining", while it was in fact raining. Even if his dream were connected with the noise of the rain." 

25. Last words: "Tell them I’ve had a wonderful life." Cancer killed him.


Ref:

Guantanamo is Great!

I thought I would have "n random things about x" as the theme of this month, but the world is so random, one cannot even keep to the resolve of being random. This news was so delicious, I have to share it with you.

Venezuelan beauty queen Dayana Mendoza visited Guantanamo Bay on March 27 and blogged her impressions at Miss Universe Blog. (Google Cache).

She is fairly effusive about it all, starting, "This week, Guantanamo!!! It was an incredible experience."

She had a great time there, talking about what it means to live there and things like that, she says, "it was truly a memorable trip."

She writes, "We also met the Military dogs, and they did a very nice demonstration of their skills. All the guys from the Army were amazing with us. We visited the Detainees camps and we saw the jails, where they shower, how the recreate themselves with movies, classes of art, books. It was very interesting." And why should it not be?

She was impressed with the water,  "The water in Guantanamo Bay is soooo beautiful! It was unbelievable, we were able to enjoy it for at least an hour.", so much so that she, "... didn't want to leave, it was such a relaxing place, so calm and beautiful."

Too bad that Gitmo is to be closed, maybe by some special Presidential dispensation, Mendoza might be allowed to stay there for ever and ever, to relax with the water and the military dogs and all?

But unfortunately, people are not so good, it looks like she got criticised so badly, the entry has been removed from the blog- The New York Times

Wednesday, April 1, 2009

16 Random Things about Clouds


1.There is a website founded by Gavin Pretor-Pinney, Cloud Appreciation Society  Its aim is to foster the understanding and appreciation of clouds.  Its manifesto states, that it was "founded on the belief that clouds are unjustly maligned and that life would be immeasurably poorer without them". With pictures of beautiful or unusual cloud formations from around the world,  the site sets out to counter  the fascism of blue-sky thinking. It has over 10,000 members worldwide and has received seven million visits in a month.

2. "Clouds are for dreamers, and their contemplation benefits the soul"- Cloud Appreciation Society.

3. Clouds in coat of arms symbolise mystery, some hidden truth.

4. A cloud is a visible mass of droplets or frozen crystals floating in the atmosphere above the surface of the Earth or another planetary body. On Earth the condensing substance is typically water vapor, which forms small droplets or ice crystals, typically 0.01 mm in diameter. When surrounded by billions of other droplets or crystals they become visible as clouds.

5. How will you identify a cloud?

Step 1
Check the shape of the cloud. Stratus clouds stretch across low the sky horizontally. These form between layers of cool air and moist, warm air and may stretch for several miles across the sky.
Step 2
Observe fluffy-looking clouds. These clouds, called cumulus clouds—whose definition in Latin means pile or heap—look like great, fluffy piles of cotton. Cumulus clouds form when moist, warm air pushes upward. You see these clouds on sunny days.
Step 3
Watch for a vertical rise in a cloud. When these clouds are forced upward by air and contain a lot of water, they become very large. This type of cloud is known as cumulonimbus, or thunderhead. These clouds cause bad weather such as thunderstorms.
Step 4
Identify wispy clouds. These are cirrus clouds. Cirrus is the Latin word for tuft or curl of hair. Some people call these clouds horses' tails. These clouds can only form at high altitudes and consist of crystals of ice.

6. In dreams, clouds, when fluffy and white, signify inner peace, spiritual harmony and compassion. It is possible that some problem in your life is about to go away. But when they are dark and stormy, it could be an outcome of  depression or anger. Your emotions are at the point of explosion. May be, you are confused.

7. Morning Glory is a meteorological phenomenon 600 miles long that rolls in from the sea to the coast of Queensland at certain times of the year. Glider pilots like to fly on top of it as though surfing a wave.

8. Denise Levertov's poem, "Clouds", starts with these lines
"The clouds as I see them, rising
urgently, roseate in the
mounting of somber power

surging in evening haste over
roofs and hermetic
grim walls"
and ends,

"Wiping my glasses and leaning westward,
clearing my mind of the day’s mist and leaning
into myself to see
the colors of truth

I watch the clouds as I see them
in pomp advancing, pursuing
the fallen sun."

9. The king of clouds is regarded as cumulonimbus, a formation so tall that its head hits the stratosphere and forms an anvil shape.

10. Then there are these Debris clouds- more than 300,000 objects in space, whizzing round the earth travelling at more than 17,000mph. Hazard to satellites, may be one day, they will make space flight impossible- covering earth in a mound of moving debris.

11. And what about Electron Cloud? Coined by Richard Feynman, this intuitive model provides a simplified way of visualizing an electron as a solution of the Schrödinger equation. It has something to do with the probability of finding an electron in a cloud of probability, which I suspect, is infinite. Because, we can not say with any certainty, where the electron actually is at any point in time, though we can describe where it ought to be. The cloud model is a kind of history which tells you where an electron has probably been and where it is likely to be going. But you can never be sure.

12. And can we forget the mushroom cloud? It is mushroom-shaped, and is  condensed water vapor or debris resulting from a very large explosion. Though they are  associated with nuclear explosions, any sufficiently large blast will uncork the mushroom.

13. And then, Cloud Cuckoo Land- an impossible state where everything is perfect. ("You're living in Cloud-cuckoo-land."). Its origin is said to be from the play, "The Birds" by Aristophanes: Pisthetairos ("Mr. Trusting") and Euelpides ("Mr. Hopeful"), tired of the Earth and Olympus, get together, and with some help from Tereus, decide to erect a perfect city between the clouds, to be named Cloud-Cuckoo-Land (Nephelokokkygia: Nephele- Cloud; Kokkux- Cuckooo).

14. Here's how Shakespeare handles the cloud- threatening, but powerless:
(King Henry VI, Part 3 .  Act V. Scene III.)  


"KING EDWARD.
Thus far our fortune keeps an upward course,
And we are grac'd with wreaths of victory.
But in the midst of this bright-shining day
I spy a black, suspicious, threat'ning cloud
That will encounter with our glorious sun
Ere he attain his easeful western bed-
I mean, my lords, those powers that the Queen
Hath rais'd in Gallia have arriv'd our coast
And, as we hear, march on to fight with us.

 CLARENCE.
A little gale will soon disperse that cloud
And blow it to the source from whence it came;
Thy very beams will dry those vapours up,
For every cloud engenders not a storm."

15. Nephology is the science of clouds, and Luke Howard is the man who made it scientific. He classified clouds in  four simple categories within the complexity of cloud forms.
Cumulus, Latin for 'heap';
Stratus, Latin for 'layer';
Cirrus, Latin for 'wispy curly hair'; and,
Nimbus, Latin for 'rain'.
And these basic forms are combined: cumulo nimbus or cirro stratus or whatever.  

16. And finally, we might forget anything, but we should always keep in mind that Every cloud has a silver lining:  It could have taken off from Milton's "Comus",
"Was I deceiv'd, or did a sable cloud
Turn forth her silver lining on the night?"

Tuesday, March 31, 2009

25 Random Things About Paul Dirac, the Original Quant.

1. Paul Dirac has said, "There is in my opinion a great similarity between the problems provided by the mysterious behavior of the atom and those provided by the present economic paradoxes confronting the world."

2. Paul Dirac has also said, "The methods of theoretical physics should be applicable to all those branches of thought in which the essential features are expressible with numbers."

3. And then, Paul Dirac has said, "Pick a flower on Earth and you move the farthest star."

4. Dirac once stated, "God used beautiful mathematics in creating the world."

5. Paul Dirac was convinced  that the quantum world could not be expressed in words or imagination. Its beauty reveals itself only in mathematical formulae. . To draw its picture would be "like a blind man sensing a snowflake. One touch and it’s gone".

6. Dirac liked Mickie Mouse and Blondie, but found Peanuts hard to understand.

7. An atheist, Dirac was buried under a gravestone chosen by his wife, Manci. It read "because God said it should be so".

8. Dirac told Oppenheimer: "Oppenheimer, they tell me you are writing poetry. I do not see how a man can work on the frontiers of physics and write poetry at the same time. They are in opposition. In science you want to say something that nobody knew before, in words which everyone can understand. In poetry you are bound to say... something that everybody knows already in words that nobody can understand."

9. At Paul Dirac's home silence was observed at every meal, so that he could concentrate on eating, and no drop of alcohol was allowed anywhere, even in recipes.

10. When Manci, his wife-to-be, wrote Dirac an angry letter asking why he had replied to none of the questions in her previous correspondence,he drew up, in tabular form, an explanation of why he could not use the endearments customary with lovers, since they were not literally true.

11. Paul Dirac's elder brother committed suicide, for which Dirac blamed his father (though Dirac clearly regarded his brother as an inferior, had not spoken to him for some years and would pass him in the street with an expressionless stare).   After Dirac won two scholarships to Cambridge, it appeared that he would lose his place for want of £5. Dirac’s father gave his son the money and made him understand that he had launched the boy’s career. After his father died in 1936, it emerged that he had not given Dirac the essential £5, although he could have done so, having hoarded more than £7,500, some 15 times his annual salary. The crucial fiver had come from the local education authority.

12. Dirac did not do talk. His fellow students invented a unit, "the Dirac", for the smallest imaginable number of words someone could utter in an hour.

13. "I never knew love or affection when I was a child," Dirac once said.

14. The only time Dirac was known to have wept was when Einstein died.

15. In the question time following one of his lectures, a student ventured that he did not understand an equation on the blackboard. Dirac remained impassive until prompted, and then replied, "That is not a question, it is a comment."

16. Looking at an impressionist painting, he remarked, "This boat looks as if it was not finished."

17. Dirac told Heisenberg: "I cannot understand why we idle discussing religion. If we are honest, and as scientists honesty is our precise duty, we cannot help but admit that any religion is a pack of false statements, deprived of any real foundation. The very idea of God is a product of human imagination.... I do not recognize any religious myth, at least because they contradict one another...."

18. Urged to read Crime and Punishment, he worked through it sentence by sentence, and concluded it was "nice", though "in one of the chapters the author makes a mistake: he describes the sun as rising twice on the same day".

19. Visiting Russia in the 1930s, he remained unaware that millions were dying of famine as a result of collectivisation and he dismissed British press reports of Stalin’s purges as exaggeration.

20. In post-war Cambridge, although still the Lucasian Professor, he was an irrelevance. They even took away his departmental parking space.

21. Manci, Dirac's wife, was [Nobelist] Eugene Wigner's sister. She would storm into meetings asking:"Where is that idiot?" Manci always called Dirac an idiot.

22. Paul dirac's grandson leo dirac has a blog; writes on business and technology trends

23. Werner Heisenberg and Dirac were sailing on a cruise ship to a conference in Japan in August, 1929. Heisenberg was a hedonist who constantly flirted and danced with women on the ship, while Dirac suffered agonies if forced into any kind of socialising or small talk. 'Why do you dance?' Dirac asked his companion. 'When there are nice girls, it is a pleasure,' Heisenberg replied. Dirac pondered this notion, then blurted out: 'But, Heisenberg, how do you know beforehand that the girls are nice?'"

24. The street on which the National High Magnetic Field Laboratory in Tallahassee, Florida, is located was named Paul Dirac Drive. There is also a road named after him in his home town of Bristol, UK.

25. Paul Adrien Maurice Dirac,  (8 August 1902  20 October 1984) was a British theoretical physicist.  In 1933, at the age of 31, Dirac became the youngest theoretician to win a Nobel prize.

Sunday, March 29, 2009

Peace in the Anti-World

When you read newspapers, which are essentially about conflicts between ideologies and people and money and power and things like that, you can't help taking a position. Sometimes you are sure where you are, and sometimes you are not so sure whether you are right. This uncertainty is the wavering of your moral compass as it searches for direction through the hazy mist of information.

But you know one thing, there is a kind of short-cut you can use. There are not many, but there are quite a few people, if you look at their track-record, they have been consistently wrong, just by checking what they say you can find the position you must avoid.

Arundhati Roy is someone who is just great at it- here she is at The Times of India., ranting against an imminent genocide.

But still there are some things I don't know who is in the right, such as Tom or Jerry, Godzilla orthe Dinosaur, Predator or the Alien (or is it the Terminator?), and very importantly, Martians or the Earthlings.

I am sure Arundhati Roy will raise her voice on these issues also and save the world and establish us all on the One Person Nation.

Friday, March 27, 2009

Mystic River- A Question of Power and Responsibility.

Yesterday I  saw the Clint Eastwood directed film, "Mystic River'. I found it depressing for the most part, and I could not understand what it was about- there were too many threads pulling in different directions.

But the film came alive for me, at this part, "The King's Wife" chapter in the DVD.


(Jimmy Markham learns that he has killed the wrong man. We see him standing with his back to us, a cross tattooed on his back from the nape of the neck to halfway down the back. This is the first time we see it, and the writing gets powerful as he starts to talk to his wife who slowly walks towards him).


Jimmy:  "I killed Dave. I killed him and threw him in the Mystic. But I killed the wrong man. That's what I've done. And I can't undo it."


Annabeth: (Embraces him from the back, over the cross) "Jimmy. I wanna feel your heart. Last night, when I put the girls to bed, I told them how big your heart was. I told them how much you loved Katie..."


Jimmy: "Annabeth..."


Annabeth: "Because you created her. And sometimes your love for her was so big, felt like your heart was gonna explode-"


Jimmy: "Please stop."


Annabeth: "I told them their daddy loved them that much too. That he had four hearts, and they were all filled up, and aching with a love that meant we would never have to worry and that their daddy would do whatever he had to for those he loved. And that is never wrong. That can never be wrong, no matter what their daddy had to do. And those girls fell asleep at peace."


Jimmy: "You said, "Last night", you knew?"
Annabeth: "Celeste called, looking for you.She was worried something might happen. She told me about Dave. Told me what she told you. What kind of wife says that about her husband? And why'd she run to you?"


Jimmy: "Why didn't you call?"


Annabeth: "Because it's like I told the girls. Their daddy's a king. And a king knows what to do and does it. Even when it's hard. And their daddy will do whatever he has to for those he loves. And that's all that matters. Because everyone's weak, Jimmy. Everyone but us. We will never be weak. And you... You could rule this town."



You know which part perked up my attention? The part where she says, "...And a king knows what to do and does it. Even when it's hard. And their daddy will do whatever he has to for those he loves. And that's all that matters..."

You know how we have argued here in this blog and elsewhere about the rights and wrongs of Bush, Israel, Sri Lankan Army... Some of us believe that the strong have to show restraint, and others that there could be no talk of restraint when it is taken as a sign of weakness.

So, I told myself, "Ah-ha!, this could apply to Bush. He did not have perfect knowledge, perfect wisdom, and if he did what he did out of love for his nation...- "....their daddy would do whatever he had to for those he loved. And that is never wrong. That can never be wrong, no matter what their daddy had to do...And a king knows what to do and does it. Even when it's hard. And their daddy will do whatever he has to for those he loves. And that's all that matters..."

Is that so? It seems a justifiable argument.

But what does this tale that she told her children accomplish? "And those girls fell asleep at peace."

This is what is so great about good films. They always leave something unsaid, something you want to find out for sure.

Thursday, March 26, 2009

Mission: Kumbabishekam

Run around. Collect eight different types of soil viz: sand from sea, river and lake, crab's nest (not sure about this, may be powdered conch), soil from snake's (termite) mound, soil stamped by elephant, soil dug by a bull with its horn, soil where the sacred Darbha grass grows;

Make long and thick ropes by twisting green Darbha grass, long enough to connect the homa(m)peetams to the moola vigrahas- these are the lifelines that transfer the powers that are invoked up by the homams and mantras to the vigrahas, making it fit for worship; the thicker the better;

Do hundreds of such and other things. Put more than a million rupees, coordinate people who don't even sit in the same room for a minute. Do this through a whole year.

Then you can conduct a Temple Kumbabishekam. But you are not finished. You still toil for 48 more days to conduct post-implementation rituals, so the temple fully is fit for worship.

Making this happen, though not comparable to launching a rocket, is indeed a mammoth task.

I was lucky to witness one the week before, and since I knew the family who executed, funded and sweated for it, I got to know all about this directly. If you are the religious type, you will say that they were blessed to have gotten a chance to do it in their lifetime.

The Kumbabishekam was for the 'Meenakshi Sundareswarar' temple of Lord Shiva, who resides with Godess Meenakshi in Kuranguputhur (a small village near Mayiladuthurai on the banks of River Cauvery).

When the germ of the idea solidified into a decision and an agreement was reached in the family to undertake the consecration of the temple, everyone was happy,they felt it was a gift to have such a chance to do a virtuous act, but no one had any clue about how demanding it could be or what exactly needed to be done. Almost everything to do with it was big: the number of things to buy, the number of things to do, the money involved, mobilizing people, getting the consent and support of villagers in sensitive decisions...

When sought, the Gurukkal handed over a 50-page notebook that contained the list of items to be purchased, since it was only a small temple. The steps and processes that make use of these items require a library, most of which the Gurukkal and Vedic Brahmanas know by heart.

Undaunted, the family, along with the support of the villagers, spent more than an year to achieve it. They starting with renovating the old temple, then they installed new moolavighrahas and vimanas, and arranged every other thing. The temple had to be completely re-built, except for the original Shivalinga, the only vigraha to survive a heist that took place a few years ago.

Some years ago, when the temple was closed and kept unused due to various reasons, some (ultra pious ?!) sticky hands managed to check-in empty-handed and uninvited, and took home literally 'heavy' stuff. The villagers say that the person/ gang who stole the things even approached them indirectly, to 'sell' the vigrahas back to the temple for a price since they found it difficult to sell them in the black market; it is also spoken about that the thieves even dumped some of the statues in a lake in the region, that were too huge and heavy to hold and hide).

As all herculean tasks always require, the people who were involved in the kumbabishekam had to jump hurdles, leap fences and penetrate walls and mountains. And they did it, all with grace and great elegance. It is a peerless feat which they have accomplished.

Doing things, making a change- it happens all around us. It might not be glamorous or spectacular, it could be as simple as repairing an old temple. But then, when you get a chance, you need to be a part of it, but not as a spectator.

I brought this home from Kuranguputhur.

Do something. Be happy.