Friday, March 13, 2009

We want Gandhiji's possessions not what he taught us


James Otis, the US based private collector, is in the news today. He is going to US supreme court to get back Gandhiji's possessions, won by Mallya a week back in an auction. He was queried by a journalist on his change of mind and about the negative feelings it may generate. In his reply he said, he has a great value for Gandhiji and feels last week's auction caused Gandhiji's photograph on the front pages of newspapers all over the world, which will help people remember the great man's teachings and his ideals. I thought to my self, "we have Gandhiji's photo in every police station and Government offices". He also went onto say that he is prompted to approach the court now as Vijay Mallya, who bought the items in the auction, is in the opposition camp. Can it get any absurd?

What was appalling was the casual way in which Otis mentioned that repossession of auctioned items would help him to renegotiate with the Indian Government on the points he is raising. Whether he is well intentioned or just a fraud, as Tushar Gandhi calls him now, the fact that we are in a position that an individual is talking and behaving like this is shame on our Government and each one of us. There was so much hue and cry about the auction and how it is important for India to bring back Gandhiji's possessions. It's an irony that a liquor baron won it in the auction.

Gandhiji taught us on how to lead a clean public life. He taught us on individual discipline. He taught us the virtues of non-violence. He taught us tolerance. He put the society ahead of the self. When one of his sons, helped the another from the common funds he was responsible for managing, Gandhiji admonished him and sent him to Chennai with just a train ticket. He was not supposed to say whose son he is and find his way to earn and live. Gandhiji's son, whose name I forgot, slept on platforms, toiled hard, earned and lived his life for a year in Chennai on his own. All this to know the importance and how difficult it is to earn money. Have no doubts. Gandhiji lived in this very land we call ourselves, where politicians, powerful and the corrupt promote self, family and their cronies.

We don't care that we have abandoned Gandhiji's ideals and teachings. In fact Gandhiji is a witness, in his framed presence, to many crimes that take place in this country. But we want things that he possessed, back in India as otherwise it would be an insult. What a hypocrisy? We must hang our heads in shame that a foreigner is reminding us of Gandhiji and his teachings. He feels, seeing Gandhiji's photo will evoke in us the principles he stood for. Hope it does.

5 comments:

  1. I think these are Otis Conditions:

    India should
    # “substantially increase the proportion of the Indian government budget spent on healthcare for the poor to shift priorities from military spending to the healthcare of the Indian people, specifically the poor”.

    # Or, “provide financial support and the good offices of Indian embassies and consulates, as well as other contacts in the Indian community, to support educational events that use the Gandhi items to promote Gandhian non-violent resistance in 78 countries around the world, one for each of the number of years Gandhiji graced us with his life on the planet”.

    Seems reasonable. But is the cost worth paying for regaining possession of Mahatma Gandhi’s pocket watch, steel-rimmed spectacles, a pair of sandals and an eating bowl and plate?

    This is somewhat hysterical. Indians have never been much of collectors, have not treasured any relic, we are painting out temple towers in green and red!

    This is just some easy way to gain the moral upper hand, it looks like. Easy to hate Otis, or blame government.

    Seeing what happened to Tagore's Nobel Medal, i feel Gandhiji is in safe hands with Otis. Let us give them back to him.

    At least his hands would be clean than that of a liquor baron (By the way, how cynical of him to go and buy Gandhiji's relics!)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Increase spending in rural sector... else we will always be embroiled in subtle civil wars.

    ReplyDelete
  3. yes, civil wars masquerading as class wars and caste wars, confusing the whole issue...

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have no doubt that Otis has lost what he had in the economic downturn and is making a sequential sale of the same item to top-off his tank again...or attempting to. The finery of his words cannot conceal his intentions.

    I have also no doubt that India will continue to be India even if the said articles remain permanently here. We are a land of symbols and symbolism, we shall remain true to our nature - like the polluted waters of the Ganga purifies our souls (if not our intestines in case you make the mistake of ingesting the liquid suspension while dipping into it), the symbols we adorn our shelves and walls with purify the environment they are intended to - police station or kuchcheri or the big round sabha we shall once again elect shortly....after all a symbolic exchange of notes is going on...

    India cannot be contaminated nor adulterated by any other than symbolism - we are like this only.

    ReplyDelete
  5. SB, great response- this is telling it as is. Thanks...

    ReplyDelete